'nother Mike (
mbarker) wrote in
wetranscripts2025-07-29 06:57 pm
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Writing Excuses 20.30: Using Why To Shape Tone
Writing Excuses 20.30: Using Why To Shape Tone
From https://writingexcuses.com/20-30-using-why-to-shape-tone
Key points: Tone? Emotional beats. The vibe. Contrasting tones. In space, something always goes wrong. Sentence level tone? Assonance, consonants, emphasis. Sentence length and word length. Punctuation. Imagery. Sensory details. Cherry red, lipstick red, or blood red?
[Season 20, Episode 30]
[Mary Robinette] This episode of Writing Excuses has been brought to you by our listeners, patrons, and friends. If you would like to learn how to support this podcast, visit www.patreon.com/writingexcuses.
[Season 20, Episode 30]
[Howard] This is Writing Excuses.
[Mary Robinette] Using Why To Shape Tone.
[Howard] I'm Howard.
[Mary Robinette] I'm Mary Robinette.
[Dan] And I'm Dan.
[Mary Robinette] Today we're going to be talking about tone. Now, I know that we did a whole episode in Season 18 on tone and mood. We're coming back to tone, because I love talking about it.
[Yay!]
[Mary Robinette] Tone is one of those words that people use when talking about fiction in a lot of different ways. The tone of horror, or the tone of the scene. What we're going to do is we're going to break down what it means, how we use it, and how it can be a tool in your toolbox. So, when we're talking about tone, what are some of the things that you all are thinking about in terms of what it means? Let's start with the meaning.
[Howard] I treat tone in fiction as an emotional word. Like a happy tone, a sad tone. I mean, I come from a music background and so the domain of the word tone is very heavily overburdened. But within the domain of writing, I think of tone as a set of emotional beats that the prose will deliver independent of what kind of story it may be. You can have a horror story that has a cheerful tone.
[Dan] I'm not sure that I have a good answer for this. I think about tone in similar ways.
[Mary Robinette] Same.
[Dan] Yeah. That tone is... tends to be primarily emotional for me. And I love picking tones that are not happy.
[Laughter]
[Mary Robinette] Really? Shocking!
[Dan] As exhibited in most of my books. I am really taken by the idea of sadness. I love sadness as, like, a tonal texture in which to tell a story. Dealing with loss, dealing with sadness, dealing with whether or not it is worth hoping for something. This was all long before I developed depression. But I find that to be such a fun thing to play with. I guess I need to ask, though, what you mean by the meaning of the tone?
[Mary Robinette] So, for me, when I'm thinking about tone… Very similar, that it's the emotion. That it tends to have words associated with it, like, oh, this has a bouncy tone, or a loving tone, or a scary tone. But I also think that you can talk about tone in a large-scale thing. It's like, this is the tone of the book. When you open the book, you're like, Nnnn, I am in for a horror thing. That it can hint at the genre, it can hint at this is the emotion that I'm going to have when I walk away from the book. But I also think that it can be within a scene. We sometimes talk about the dark night of the soul, which is a specific tone. That there's… Like, there's a specific mood, there's a vibe that's going on. I'm not sure that tone and vibe are that different, honestly. But it exists in the same way that in a horror book where you… Instead of having the all is lost moment, you have the aha, you're going to get away… Nope, nope. You get sucked back in…
[Dan] Yeah.
[Chuckles]
[Mary Robinette] To hell. And so, there are places where you're going to lay two tones against each other. But the overall tone of the whole piece, the overall vibe, the sensation, the experience that the reader is going to have… That… There's… Um… It's still coloring that contrasting moment.
[Dan] Yes. I see what you mean now. I'm thinking about my book, Partials, where I establish the tone right off the bat, the very first scene, very first chapter, is about a dead baby. The plague that has killed everyone is still around, and the baby is born and passes away. And it's horrible, and that's part of the point, is because I want to establish right up front that is the tone that we are dealing with in this book. Which is not to say that the entire book will be dismal. In fact, most of the book is much more upbeat than that. Because another thing that I was specifically trying to play with in that series was the idea that the adults who remember the world that we lost our always sad and angry about it, whereas the kids who have grown up post-apocalypse, this is the only world they've ever known. They are finding joy in ways that the adults never do. And so there is… That was the easiest best way to get that juxtaposition across was to present the horrible thing and then show the different reactions that everyone in the book has to it. And so that kind of overriding sense of this is a world where babies die is important to establish the stakes, to establish what the emotions are going to be like. But then it also makes the joy and the happiness that the main characters experience that much more meaningful, because you know what they are feeling joy in spite of.
[Howard] Yeah. I am… I keep tripping over just the word tone in context with my music background. And I'm thinking of pieces of music where what fiction, in prose, we would call tone, in music we would call timbre. We would call maybe texture… When you have the brass all standing on a note versus when you have the strings all standing on a note. It's very, very different. That is analogous to, in your prose, the word choice. The line level word choice. But Dan, when you talk about the content of… I am telling the story of a baby dying, that is the minor key versus the major key, the tri-tone versus the dominant seven. That is the tone of the content as opposed to the tone of the turn of phrase. And as a humorist, I'm always balancing the two of those, because if I take the tri-tone, if I take the very dissonant tall jazz nineteenth chord and play it with nothing but woodwinds and harps, that's almost silly. And it's light, and it's airy, and I love taking the tone of my words, the tone of my prosaic turns of phrase, and contrasting them against the tone of the content of what I'm writing. That is a chewy delight for me that I just never tire of doing.
[Dan] Oh, man, that's one of my favorite things to do.
[Mary Robinette] Absolutely.
[Dan] If I can get a reader to feel two contrasting emotions at the same time, I know I have succeeded at something.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah. So, as we're talking, you've made me think about a thing that was happening when I was working on Martian Contingency that goes back to the last episode where we were talking about authorial intent. I honestly, when I sat down to write that, what I wanted to do, I just wanted to write a cozy. I just wanted to… Like, my characters have been having a really tough time. I just wanted them to have a nice time on Mars. I just wanted to write about let's have a party. Let's have meals. This is… Let's grow some plants. This is what I wanted to write. And also, the book before that in the series is Relentless Moon which is a really intense thriller. And I knew that that motion for the reader, that coming into this tone of we're growing some plants, that the complete lack of tension was not going to work. So I had to come up with a tone and a reason… Like, I had to come up with an authorial intention for it. But I came up with a tone of tension and keeping tension on my characters all the way through. But most of the plot points, most of the things that are actually happening in the book, I am… Like, there are multiple parties in this book. There's multiple discussions of clothing and sexy fun times and food and gardening. And I'm masking it under this tone of tension. I have created the tension using authorial intent and all of the other tools that we've been talking about. But I had to put that tone in of oh, no, things are going to go terribly, terribly wrong, and I did that on the first page when I had my character looking at the beautiful sky and thinking how lovely it is, and then think, but of course, this was space, and in space, something always goes wrong. And using that contrasting tone between those two things to create tension for the reader that I then play with through the whole book.
[Mary Robinette] Speaking of creating contrast, we are going to take a pause now. And when we come back, we're going to talk more about how to actually use this concept.
[Mary Robinette] So I find that when I am learning a new tool, that one of the things that works for me is to deal with it on a fairly small… Small level. And then I can scale it up to see how it works on something bigger. So when you are talking about the tone of a sentence, what are the pieces that were using to manipulate the tone of a sentence?
[Howard] Assonance and dissonance… Or assonance and consonants. Repeated vowel sounds, repeated consonant sounds. Or the absence thereof. Putting emphasis… Almost like rhymes. Words with similar emphatic patterns, similar accent patterns. Putting rhymes in. Emphasized and non-emphasized places. If this sounds like poetry, I'm so sorry.
[Chuckles]
[Howard] That's kind of the way my brain works. But when I'm crafting, when I'm really trying to craft one sentence that matters, the whole shape, the lilt, the beat, the song of the sentence is governed by every one of these pieces. And… I mean, I can't think about that for every sentence I write, for an entire book, but it's when I know, gosh, like, first line, I have to establish tone. I will shape that sentence very, very carefully.
[Dan] Yeah. A lot of it is also sentence length, word length. Am I using big, long words, am I using short ones? How much punctuation is in there? There's all of these little tools you can use to change whether a sentence feels very fast and punchy, whether it feels fast and simple, whether it feels long and mellifluous. Lots of word length and sentence length and punctuation are tools that I use all the time.
[Howard] The tintinnabulation of the bells, bells, bells.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah.
[Howard] Ah. So tasty.
[Mary Robinette] Yeah, and it is that like word choice, sentence structure, the imagery that I choose. Those are the things that I will look at. The difference between describing a fallen leaf is moldy or golden red. Like, those are both leaves that are dead, but they convey a different tone. So, some of what I'm also looking at is shared context.
[Dan] Yes!
[Laughter]
[Howard] [garbled] when you say shared context. I lean into sensory details. We often forget when we're writing to describe what a room smells like. What a small room sounds like, when empty as you walk through it, versus a large room, versus the great outdoors when you walk… Those are different acoustic spaces. They… At least… Okay, I have an audio engineering background, I can't not hear these things. But I think even to the untrained ear, you can tell if you're in a small room versus a large room, even if the lights are out. And if the lights are out, and the experience the character is having is hearing that they have stepped from a small alcove into a larger room, you've established the tone. And it's probably pretty cool.
[Mary Robinette] You're making me think about and wonder if our readers can tell the difference between the episodes that we record when we are all sitting in the same room, which we are doing right now, and the ones where we are on zoom and we are separated, we're distant.
[Howard] And I think the answer to that question is Alex wants the answer to be no…
[Laughter]
[Howard] [garbled] That's the guy who masters our episodes, and so masterfully masks the sounds of the ship or the sounds of the…
[Mary Robinette] But it…
[Howard] Lawnmower outside my window.
[Dan] Yeah, but there's so much more to it than that. There is how much we step on each other. Like, just now, you were still talking and I talked over you. And when we record on Zoom, we tend to not do that as much. Or two people will start out talking at the same time, and then stop, like there's a lot of…
[Yup... bup... nup...]
[Dan] Very weird tonal etiquette kind of things that we do that are very different.
[Mary Robinette] And these are the kinds of very small nuanced things that often a reader won't notice, there won't be a conscious piece of it. So, sometimes you're going into a scene and you may not have a conscious thought, as you are writing, about what this tone is going to be. And this is something that I think you can go back and layer in later. You can add in… If you want a little bit of tension, you can look at the way the characters are interacting with each other, you can look at what are the… Where am I adding in words like tintinnabulation to direct our attention.
[Howard] To the first line.
[Chuckles]
[Howard] You've got my attention.
[Laughter]
[Howard] You have got my attention. If you describe something, if you describe a car as cherry-red, or if you describe a car as lipstick red, or blood red, it might… I mean, those might all be the same color of car to your mind's eye, but to the reader, the blood red car is in a very different book than the cherry-red car.
[Mary Robinette] I think that that, Howard, actually is a great segue for us talking about homework.
[Mary Robinette] What I want you to think about is to take this idea of tone. Just thinking about it in terms of these very broad things that we're talking about, word choice, sentence structure, the feeling that you want the reader to have. And I want you to have your character do an action. They're just going to have a very simple thing. We're going to write a little vignette in which a character is pouring tea for a beloved partner. I want you to try for a joyful tone. Everything in this is just joy. The tea is joyful. Everything is joyful. Think about the word choices, the sentence structure, the way the character… What the characters notice. The imagery that you're showing us. And I want you to do it again. But I want you to try for a tone of terror. It's still tea, it is still a beloved partner. One character is pouring tea for the other. And there is a sense of terror for the entire scene.
[Mary Robinette] You're out of excuses. Now go write.